The Cuisinart Grilling Prep & Serve Trays are essential BBQ accessories, featuring durable, dishwasher-safe nesting trays designed to prevent cross-contamination and streamline your grilling process. Perfectly sized for everything from raw meats to serving cooked food, these Cuisinart trays make outdoor cooking safer and more convenient.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This means when you purchase through links on this page, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Grilling Trays – Complete Review 2025
Grilling trays have become an indispensable tool for serious barbecue enthusiasts, and the Cuisinart Grilling Prep & Serve Trays are a leading example of how to do it right. After spending weeks testing these trays during peak grilling season, I’ve seen firsthand how they solve one of the biggest challenges in outdoor cooking: safe and efficient food handling. Juggling multiple plates for raw and cooked food is clumsy and, more importantly, poses a significant risk of cross-contamination. These Cuisinart grilling trays offer a simple, elegant solution. They are designed not just for transport, but as a complete system for prepping, carrying, and serving, making your entire outdoor entertaining experience smoother. Whether you’re a seasoned pitmaster or a weekend warrior, understanding how dedicated grilling trays can streamline your process is a game-changer. This review will dive deep into what makes this particular set a must-have piece of kitchen serveware for anyone who loves to grill.
What Makes These Grilling Trays Stand Out?
In a market full of generic cooking accessories, the Cuisinart set distinguishes itself with thoughtful design focused on safety and convenience. These aren’t just any plastic platters; they are a purpose-built system for better barbecuing. The large surface area (17″ x 10.5″) is perfectly sized for holding everything from a half-dozen burgers to a large brisket, making them a versatile barbecue platter. After extensive use, a few features truly shine.
- Cross-Contamination Prevention: This is the headline feature. The set includes two color-coded nesting trays: a red tray for raw meat and a black tray for cooked food. This simple visual cue is brilliant for cross-contamination prevention, eliminating guesswork and enhancing food safety.
- Durable, Food-Safe Materials: The trays are crafted from BPA-free, shatter-resistant melamine. This makes them a lightweight yet incredibly durable food safe tray. During testing, they held over 15 pounds of pork shoulder without any sign of bending or stress. As customer reviews also confirm, the durability of these melamine trays is a major selling point.
- Effortless Cleanup: After a long session at the grill, the last thing anyone wants is a complicated cleanup. Being a fully dishwasher safe tray set is a massive advantage. They came out of the dishwasher looking brand new every time, with no warping or discoloration.
- Space-Saving Design: The two grilling trays nest together perfectly, saving valuable cabinet space. This smart design makes them easy to store and carry as a single unit.
Real-World Performance Testing
To put these grilling trays to the test, I used them for a classic backyard barbecue. I started by seasoning six large burger patties on the red meat prep tray. The size was perfect, providing ample space without crowding. Carrying the raw patties to the grill was stable and easy. Once the burgers were cooked to perfection, I transferred them to the black BBQ serving tray. The clear color difference provided peace of mind, especially with kids running around. The trays performed exactly as advertised, creating a seamless and safe workflow from kitchen to grill to table. For more complex tools to perfect your grilling, see our review on the best wireless meat thermometer.
The melamine material felt robust, a significant step up from flimsy disposable pans. One minor limitation is that they are not heat-proof, so you can’t place them directly on a hot grill side-table, but this is standard for melamine trays. The cleanup was impressively simple—a quick rinse and into the dishwasher they went. From a performance standpoint, these grilling trays delivered on their promise of making the entire process safer and more organized. They’ve quickly become one of my essential cooking accessories for any barbecue event.
Grilling Trays vs Competitors
When comparing the Cuisinart grilling trays to competitors like the Weber Grill Prep ‘N’ Serve Trays or generic stainless steel options, a few differences are clear. While stainless steel trays offer superior heat resistance, they are often heavier, more expensive, and lack the color-coding system for cross-contamination prevention. The Weber set is functionally similar but is often priced higher. The Cuisinart set hits the sweet spot of affordability, durability, and safety-focused design. For the price, getting two purpose-built, high-quality melamine trays is an excellent value. If you’re looking for other ways to improve your cooking experience, check out our guide on finding a non toxic air fryer for healthier meals indoors.
Who Should Buy the Cuisinart Grilling Prep & Serve Trays?
This product is ideal for a few specific types of grillers:
- The Safety-Conscious Cook: If your top priority is preventing foodborne illness, this is the best meat prep tray set for you. The red and black tray system is foolproof and essential for safe handling of raw and cooked meats.
- The Frequent Entertainer: Anyone who hosts regular barbecues will appreciate the efficiency and stylish presentation. These trays function as an excellent BBQ serving tray, transitioning perfectly from grill-side workhorse to a presentable barbecue platter for guests.
- The Organized Griller: If you value a tidy and efficient workspace, the seamless workflow and space-saving nesting trays design will be a perfect fit for your Cuisinart grilling setup.
However, professional caterers or those needing to transport extremely large quantities of food might find the 17×10.5 inch size slightly limiting. For most home users, though, the size is more than adequate. For more tips on creating the perfect backyard, explore our guide to professional landscaping services.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Are these melamine grilling trays heat resistant enough to rest on a grill’s side shelf?
A: No, melamine is not designed to withstand high heat. You should not place these trays on a hot surface. They are intended for prepping, carrying, and serving, not for direct heat contact.
Q: What are the exact dimensions of these Cuisinart grilling trays?
A: Each tray measures 17 inches by 10.5 inches (17″ x 10.5″). This size is large enough to hold approximately 6 large burgers or a whole chicken, making them very versatile for most grilling tasks.
Q: How do these trays effectively ensure cross-contamination prevention?
A: The system’s effectiveness lies in its simplicity. According to Cuisinart’s design, the bright red tray is used exclusively for raw meat, while the neutral black tray is used for cooked food, eliminating the risk of accidental mix-ups.
Q: Can I use the black tray as a barbecue platter for serving guests?
A: Absolutely. The black tray has a sleek, subtle design that makes it a perfect piece of kitchen serveware. It’s stylish enough for serving guests directly at the table during any outdoor entertaining event.
Q: Are these grilling trays difficult to clean if they have greasy residue?
A: Not at all. They are designed as a dishwasher safe tray set. As many users also note, they clean up very easily, even with greasy barbecue sauce, both in the dishwasher and by hand.
